This blog reflects my deep interest in the different ways the various cultures and subcultures in this world conceive of the world and our lives within it. I was born in Asia, hold a UK passport, lived for most of my adult life in France, and now live in the US as a resident alien, working as a psychotherapist in private practice in San Francisco. Issues of cultural identity and displacement are very close to 'home' for me, and for many of my clients.

Monday, June 17, 2024

Americans vs Japanese reactions to 'bad' feelings

I just read about a fascinating study called 'Feeling Bad Is Not Always Unhealthy', conducted by Shinobu Kitayama, professor of psychology at the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.

Kitayama surveyed American and Japanese participants, and in the Americans he found a correlation between feeling so-called negative emotions (for example, sadness) and increased inflammation. But--and here's the fascinating bit-- there was no such correlation with the Japanese. 

Kitayama's conclusion was that Americans believe 'negative' emotions are harmful, and so they are!

Americans are so sure that 'negative' emotions are bad for them, that they feel anxious about feeling them--in other words, Americans feel bad about feeling bad, and their body's reaction reflects that extra layer of stress. Americans feel threatened by such feelings, whereas Japanese do not.

Kitayama concludes that for Americans, feeling bad is more stressful than it is for Japanese, because it is felt as a “source of threat to self-image”, whereas in Japanese culture, it is understood to be “natural and integral to life”.

You can read more about it here.


No comments:

Post a Comment